Tuesday, December 17, 2013

A rant on "our friends"

Okay, I have something that's bothering me and I need to work it out.

Friends.

There's a trend these days to call everyone in the child's classroom or group "our friends." I can see how that would seem like a positive move, emphasizing togetherness and closeness and friendliness in general.

But I'll tell you one thing: Robert is SO confused. He's never had a real friend. He's three. So when his preschool teacher says, "We'll start the story when our friends are all sitting quietly", or maybe something like, "Some of our friends are still learning to share", Robert learns that a "friend" is anyone. He's not learning that anyone can be a friend. See the difference?

When I ask Robert who his friends are, he thinks I want a class list.

He's told me a couple times, "Some friends are nice and some friends are mean."

Really?! 'Cuz I expect my friends to be nice to me, even when it hurts.

Before preschool started, Robert had one friend. A real friend. Well, as real as a 3-year-old can have, anyway. Robert doesn't classify that boy as a friend anymore because he doesn't go to school with him. He has NO WORD to describe that relationship. Am I the only one disturbed by this notion?

But now I'll tell you another thing, and this is probably the real issue at hand: It's not easy for me to throw around the term "friend." I may have known someone for five years, but that doesn't make them my friend. I have about 10 real friends, and more than one is related to me. See what I mean? Short list, real relationships. I truly care about these people and their lives.

Friends are not the kids you simply endure at school. Friends are not everyone. Friends are people who invest in the relationship. They give as much as they ask. They are regenerating and enduring. Timeless.

Robert is three, I know, what's the big deal? He'll figure it out when he's old enough to care. Sure, sure, sure. I'm trying to be okay with this. Really, I am. This is clearly MY problem, not his. I just wish I could give him another word for that trusting, enduring relationship that comes along every once in a great while.

Real friend? Close friend? Dear friend? Good friend? True friend? Bah humbug. There's a reason the word "acquaintance" exists.

4 comments:

  1. I definitely get this, even into adulthood. Sometimes when I'm talking to my sister about some play group I was at I'll say, "My friend," but then I think, well we do things together because we've been pushed together by chance of where we live and where we got to church and the age of our children but we aren't really friends. She doesn't know me beyond just a superficial knowledge and frankly I prefer it that way...but I don't really have a good other word for people I spend time with.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Do you think he would understand a simplified explanation of how people use the word "friend" differently? (People use the word "love" differently.) He may be able to understand that his teacher is using it in a different way than other people.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I know what you mean. It isn't just you. Sometimes I say "friend" when it would take longer to define the relationship than it would to finish the story, but "friend" means something specific to me, too. I can understand Buddy's confusion when "friend" just means "classmate." Just keep redefining it for him to include those outside his class, and he'll figure it out.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I just read a post about must friends (those closest to you) trust friends (those not in your inner circle but whom you still consider trustworthy) rust friends (defacto friends since you have known each other so long) and just friends (the kind of friend Crys described.) I this this little rhyme scheme is from a book about boys/men's friendships, but I can't remember the author's name. Gretchen Rubin wrote the post I read.

    I think if you use "classmates" Robert will figure out that at school they're called friends and at home they're called classmates. *shrug* figuring out how to define friendship is a lifelong thing. Also it might not hurt to expand your definition of friend -- I know when I let myself call someone who may or may not really be my friend "friend" it actually strengthens our friendship in my mind. And it is thrilling to be introduced as someone's friend or to be called a friend. So, spread the love! But yeah, let's not spread fake love. Fake love is dumb.

    Just yesterday I had one of my fledgling friends over and her son was going to meet levi for the first time. I told him a "new friend" was coming over.

    What do you call that super special best friend type friendship? BFF, Bestie, true friend, close friend, bosom friend, soul sister, kindred spirit; "best bud" is currently Benjamin's choice.

    ReplyDelete