Neither house is stunningly beautiful at first glance. That's okay. I like the idea of living undercover (that's a blog post for another day). They both get our kids into better elementary schools and they both have more than one bathroom. Both also happen to be on larger plots of land with good potential for garden and orchard. That's just about where the similarities end. Those are the most important qualifications for our new home...for the moment. It's almost a coincidence that they both happen to be within our current ward boundaries.

I'm not madly in love with either one. I think about them. I obsess over how our family would fit into each one. I envision family meals, hours of homework, out-of-town guests, late nights, and sullen teenagers rattling around inside. I see my kids playing in the yard, reading in the front room, and snuggling with me by the fireplace. Yes, both houses fit within my desired range of suitability. I like one house's layout better and the other house's location better. If I had to choose this moment between layout and location, I would pick location. I might have a different answer for you tomorrow :)
I'll spare you the house-to-house feature comparison. I've mulled it over ad nauseum. No, my purpose in blogging about this is to make sense of the nebulous feeling that it's just not adding up somewhere.
My Dream:
Modest home that's easy to maintain inside
Private space for everyone
Public space large enough for entertaining periodically
Large, private backyard with ample sun and space for garden, orchard, and a few laying hens
Excellent schools within walking/biking distance
Weekly shopping within walking/biking distance
Good friends within walking/biking distance
Church building and Bobby's work within a few minutes drive
Bobby's Dream (as far as I can decipher, if he even has an ideal house in mind):
Close to work
Yard for playing
Easy to maintain landscaping
Walking distance to elementary school
Low maintenance home (newer roof, appliances, windows, etc.)
At least one bedroom and bathroom on ground level
Alice's Dream:
Basement to hide in during tornados
Chimney
Sunroom for her craft table and supplies
Robert's Dream:
Dog/Squirrel/Rabbit/Bird/Cat to chase
Train/Truck/Car to climb all over
Ugh. Both houses seem to meet all my expectations on paper! It should add up into "this one is right for us", but it simply doesn't. I just can't figure it out. I can't choose one. Does that mean they're both wrong? Does that mean anything at all? If I had to choose right now, I would choose one and just make it work. Yet somehow, choosing one of these homes at this point feels more like a "Charlotte and Mr. Collins" match than an "Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy" match. Either one would make a practical and comfortable home, but I really want to LOVE my next home...sigh.
Or is this whole selection process more like "Choose your love. Love your choice"?


